News

Back

Back to nature in the big city

How EBRD Green Cities is harnessing nature-based solutions to solve urban problems

 

“Nature-based solutions” is a term for all solutions that use the natural world to mitigate the effects of climate change. It sounds rural, but the phrase covers multiple possibilities, from tree planting to soak up carbon emissions to flood protection through providing more green space – and so is increasingly used to provide effective and cost-effective solutions in cities too.

 

The way urban nature-based solutions can work, says Dr David Tyler, EBRD Associate Director and water sector specialist, is by providing “a softer approach to the hard-engineered conventional solution – one which is arguably also cheaper, but has added benefits, too, particularly in terms of amenity and introducing nature.”

 

Media interest in nature-based solutions has grown since they became a campaign issue in the run-up to the UK presidency of the COP26 global climate summit, due this November.

 

Among the adventurous early projects now being conceptualised are several in the parts of the world where finance is provided by the EBRD, a development bank at the forefront of climate finance, which operates around central and eastern Europe, Central Asia and the southern and eastern Mediterranean region – notably in some of the 47 cities already working to improve their sustainability through the innovative EBRD Green Cities programme.

 

The idea of this €3 billion programme is to help each member city identify, prioritise and tackle the challenges it faces in becoming more sustainable, through a tailor-made programme of improvements drawn up with the support of EBRD experts. (The thinking behind the programme is that cities, where an ever higher proportion of the world’s population choose to live, are the source of three-quarters of greenhouse gas emissions, and thus an important focus of climate action.)

 

Where nature-based solutions come into this planning, Tyler says, is in providing new answers to questions such as, “how can a city increasingly plagued by heavy rainfall, which brings localised flooding that can endanger lives, deal most sensibly with it?” The conventional urban-planning wisdom is to collect and convey away water pouring down from rooftops through a network of underground pipes. But as cities grow, drawing all that water away through an ever-increasing network of pipes is a very expensive approach. As Tyler says, “the wisdom increasingly is to bring in more sustainable urban development solutions – a way of including nature in planning and design.”

 

An effective nature-based solution is to manage excessive rainwater through localised solutions ranging from green roofs, artificial basins, grass embankments to ponds with reeds that capture and use the rainwater as the first line of defence against flooding. These are called Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems, Tyler explains: “When it rains heavily, the water is attenuated in these green pockets, and stored locally. Once the storm is over, the water will seep back gradually into the conventional system in a more controlled way”.

 

The beauty is all in the simplicity. A water retention pocket might be as basic as, say, a small patch of green land, containing an artificial pond with reeds, between blocks of flats. They often have the added benefit of being more aesthetic – softer in appearance, with the plants providing micro-habitats for small animals, birds and insects.  

 

One example Tyler cites of a city that could benefit from this approach is Varna, in Bulgaria, which joined EBRD Green Cities in June 2019 and began consultations on its Green City Action Plan soon afterwards. One focus has been the rehabilitation of key segments of Varna’s water infrastructure, strengthening the city's climate resilience and improving resource efficiency.

 

“They have this problem with rainwater running down the streets causing severe localised flooding. Conceptually this is the type of solution we are imagining for Varna.”

 

“We talked two years ago about whether they were interested in sustainable urban draining systems and now we are actively considering these types of solution - a softer engineered approach that works in partnership with existing systems, using green features within urban environments.”

 

Another flood-prone member city of EBRD Green Cities is Chisinau, the capital of Moldova. Here the solution being examined is to re-engineer the River Bic, reintroducing more natural features along its edges to help control the combined effect of river and storm water more sustainably.

 

“Rainwater from streets ends up in rivers and when those rivers are also surcharged the risk of flooding is high. Here the idea is to deliberately slow down the path of the river, by looking at the catchment and where flooding occurs … introducing something that is more natural in combination with traditional flood defences.”

 

Managed realignment is another option in flood management. One in London is located on the outer reaches of the River Thames, protected by a river barrier in the huge estuary that goes eastward to Essex – but now with a more natural area too, where “the UK Environment Agency very cleverly deliberately broke the defence in front of the Thames barrier, and have created an area of natural habitat that intentionally floods when there’s a sea surge - only maybe once every year or two – which is now part of a series of natural defences for London.”

 

“This is what Chisinau is thinking of, too - a park that might occasionally flood, but in a place where you want it to flood rather than trying to push the problem away by building canals or, worse, letting the city flood,” says Tyler, adding that urban planners were being lined up to “help understand how we can reengineer natural features to protect the city and also create public amenity space.”

 

A third way of controlling stormwater and river flooding is being considered in the Albanian capital Tirana, where the city administration plans to develop an orbital forest, initially by persuading local citizens to donate individual trees. The orbital forest is to be located partly within Tirana’s flood plain where high river water spills over:

 

“When the river is flowing in wet conditions, the trees will slow the flow of water and, in a similar way to that embankment, add protection and reduce the risk of flooding in the city. By growing an orbital forest you also improve air quality – a dual benefit. The third component is that it’s a very nice natural feature, which is where I understand the Mayor has been engaging with the community to sponsor planting trees.”

 

While the natural benefits of these plans are clear and intuitive, the idea of nature-based solutions is so new that ways of working out how to count and cost such investments are still being developed. Questions under consideration include how to measure the benefit, and demonstrate whether a nature-based solution works better than a conventional engineering solution, as well as whether such investments might be paid for by the city in question through a small tax rise, Tyler says:

 

“How do you value the benefit of a solution? We have to do a bit of extra work on that. Developing this work is requiring us to think differently about how to demonstrate the value proposition. The value is difficult to monetise.

 

A way of measuring, for instance, flood protection measures is to count how much money a city saves if there is less flooding after the measures are introduced, he adds. “In case of a flooding solution, you’d establish the frequency of flooding and who is impacted. Then you’d understand the cost of that impact on people and commerce. With a flood protection scheme, you measure the reduced flood risk, more importantly the cost of avoiding flooding.”

 

The added benefit of a nature-based solution – the value to public amenity of creating an attractive green space – is also difficult to put a monetary value on. “We are including that in our solution, so we are having to work a bit differently. There’s a lot of evidence that this can be a cost-effective way forward. But we’re talking here about engineering work which still needs managing and maintaining, but is different to conventional infrastructure. We have yet to fully understand how to invest in that kind of infrastructure.”

 

This is where the consultation process each city undergoes as it draws up its tailor-made Green City Action Plan (GCAP) within the EBRD Green Cities process is especially helpful, Tyler says, as it allows each member city to explore nature-based solutions that have worked elsewhere in the world and, if appropriate, adapt them. “We won’t always find a nature-based solution, but if there is a legitimate, cost-effective, multiple-benefit approach then we should be promoting it. It may be new to us, but these solutions have been well rehearsed and well tested elsewhere in the world. We need to use the GCAPs in a deliberate way to tease out opportunities.”

 

By Vanora Bennett

 

EBRD lends Izmir €125 million to build new metro line - 28.07.21

EBRD Green Cities joins the Leadership for Urban Climate Investment (LUCI) - 19.07.21

Signing Ceremony - Green Cities Action Plan for Ankara Metropolitan Municipality - 08.07.2021

Energy, cities and EBRD Green Cities’ Energy Compact pledge - 25.06.2021

Amman GCAP launched for implementation - 14.06.2021

Sarajevo’s GCAP formally adopted by the Cantonal Assembly - 10.06.2021

Belgrade adopts its Green City Action Plan – 09.06.2021

Green Cities Annual Conference 2021: call for green finance and closer partnerships - 09.06.2021

Back to nature in the big city - 07.06.2021

EBRD Green Cities Annual Conference 2021: IEA’s Fatih Birol as keynote speaker - 07.06.2021

EBRD Green Cities welcomes Dnipro in Ukraine as its 49th member - 07.06.21

EBRD Green Cities welcomes Samarkand as its 48th member - 07.06.21

YeTTB Yashil shaharlar dasturi Samarqandni 48-a'zo sifatida qutlaydi - 07.06.21

Программа ЕБРР «Зеленые города» приветствует Самарканд в качестве 48-го участника - 07.06.21

Meet the Green Vision of Warsaw – through the city's new information platform - 01.06.2021

Istanbul joins EBRD Green Cities urban sustainability programme - 03.05.2021

EBRD Green Cities welcomes 6th of October City to its programme - 22.04.21

برنامج المدن الخضراء التابع للبنك الأوروبي لإعادة الإعمار والتنمية يرحب بانضمام مدينة 6 أكتوبر

Skopje to introduce first Bus Rapid Transit system in Western Balkans - 21.04.21

EBRD supports district heating improvements in Dushanbe - 14.04.21

New trolleybuses hit the road in Balti, Moldova - 01.04.21

Noile troleibuze au fost puse în circulație la Bălți - 01.04.21

Policies to make your city greener - 31.03.21

Women Leading on Green: a female perspective on sustainable planning - 11.03.21

Green City Mayor Erion Veliaj honoured as a hero of sustainable mobility - 03.03.21

Public consultation on draft GCAP for Belgrade - 25.02.21

Balti launches public consultation on environmental challenges - 20.02.21

Helping Polish ex-coal mining city of Wałbrzych revitalise its economy - 14.01.21

Amman to introduce new bus fleet under EBRD Green Cities programme - 31.12.20

مدينة عمان تطرح أسطولاً جديداً من الحافلات في إطار برنامج المدن الخضراء التابع للبنك الأوروبي لإعادة

Chisinau landfill revamp financed by EBRD, EIB, EU, its members, Moldova and Norway - 16.12.20

EBRD lends Ankara bus company €57.1 million to renew bus fleet - 10.12.2020

Electric buses for a greener Batumi - 04.12.20

Warszawa rozpoczyna prace nad „Planem działań na rzecz środowiska i klimatu” - 03.12.2020

Work starts on Warsaw’s Green City and Climate Action Plan - 03.12.20

New “GCAP 2.1” announced at sixth EBRD Green Cities webinar - 24.11.20

Flagship EBRD Green Cities doubles in size - 19.11.2020

Дан старт работе проекта «План действий «Зеленый город» (ПДЗГ)» - 10.11.20

Kick-off meeting for Dushanbe's Green City Action Plan - 10.11.20

EBRD, EU and multi-donor E5P-financed electric “green” buses arrive in Batumi - 20.10.2020

Green and inclusive: EBRD Green Cities webinar - 20.10.20

Ceremony marks Split becoming 41st EBRD Green City - 16.10.20

Putting 'Nature, people and planet at the heart of our economy' - 07.10.2020

EBRD and EU finance solid waste management in western Ukraine - 07.10.2020

Global Infrastructure Forum: panel on Green Cities and Smart Solutions - 07.10.20

How ‘smart’ can keep cities safer from pandemics- 07.07.2020

The Green Frontier Webinar - 01.07.20

Transition to Recovery Webinar - 09.06.20

EBRD welcomes Chisinau’s Green City Action Plan - 04.06.2020

EBRD welcomes Iasi, Romania, as 42nd Green City - 04.06.2020

EBRD finances modernisation of Tbilisi metro - 30.04.2020

It's good to talk: an impressive first EBRD Green Cities webinar - 29.04.2020

COVID-19: A message of solidarity - 15.05.2020

East Kazakhstan leadership act to transform two cities - 12.02.2020

STUDY ON URBAN VENTILATION CORRIDOR IN SARAJEVO – 01.10.2019

How Pristina can become a Green City - 24.09.2019

Novi Sad in Serbia to buy 30 CNG buses with €7m loan in EBRD urban greening programme - 23.08.2019

EBRD to improve water supply in Banja Luka - 13.09.2019

Shymkent joins EBRD Green Cities programme - 22.07.2019

Building a Better and More Sustainable Future for Cities - 08.07.2019

Cairo becomes 30th participant in fast-growing EBRD Green Cities - 03.07.2019

Green Climate Fund makes €87 million available to EBRD Green Cities - 2.7.2019

EBRD helps Moldova’s second largest city buy more new trolleybuses -03.06.2019

Fast-growing EBRD Green Cities signs up its 25th city - 08.05.2019

The Pearl of the Black Sea Goes Green - 28.03.2019

Skopje joins EBRD’s Green Cities programme - 27.03.2019

Kiev joins innovative EBRD Green Cities programme - 18.03.2019

EBRD to finance low-emission buses for Skopje - 29.01.2019

Podgorica joins EBRD Green Cities - 20.12.2018

Ulaanbaatar joins EBRD Green Cities - 30.11.2018

Preparing Zenica hospital for the future - 12.10.2018

EBRD and international donors improve solid waste management in Lviv - 01.06.2018

Amman joins EBRD Green Cities programme - 09.05.2018

EBRD’s Green Cities Framework kicks off in Minsk - 04.05.2018

Green buses on the streets of green city Tbilisi - 19.12.2017

EBRD puts on the heating in Banja Luka 13.11.2017

Tbilisi Green City Action Plan approved by local authorities - 29.09.2017

EBRD and multi-donor E5P fund to finance electric “green” buses for Batumi - 14.07.2017

EBRD provides €25 million loan to Sarajevo water - 11.05.2017

Show us your green #EBRDcity - 21.03.2017

Making Chisinau greener - 06.12.2016

How to become a Green City - 17.10.2016

Warsaw’s ‘emission reduction pathways’ workshops - 02-09.07.2021

Almaty Stakeholder Consultation Workshop - 07 & 08.07.2021

Event on “100 Climate Neutral Cities in Europe by 2030” – 21.06.2021

EBRD Green Cities Annual Conference 2021 - 08 & 09.06.2021

EBRD YEŞİL ŞEHİRLER YILLIK KONFERANSI 2021 - 08 & 09.06.2021

CONFÉRENCE ANNUELLE 2021 DE LA BERD SUR LES VILLES VERTES - 08 & 09.06.2021

ЕЖЕГОДНАЯ КОНФЕРЕНЦИЯ ЕБРР «ЗЕЛЕНЫЕ ГОРОДА» 2021 ГОД - 08 & 09.06.2021

08 & 09.06.21 - المؤتمر السنوي للمدن الخضراء 2021 للبنك الأوروبي لإعادة الإعمار والتنمية

Developing a green vision and objectives for Balti - 03 & 04.06.2021

Green Cities and Green Development Prospects Workshop - 07.06.2021

Kyiv GCAP stakeholder workshop on the city’s vision, objectives and actions – 11.06.2021

CogX Festival 2021 – Financing and designing net zero cities - 15.06.2021

Warsaw Green City Action Plan Series of Stakeholder Workshops - 17.05.2021

Dushanbe Green City Action Plan First Stakeholder Workshop - 18.05.2021

Pristina Green City Action Plan Actions Workshop - 28.04.2021

Mariupol Green City Action Plan: Launch event and first stakeholder workshop - 29.04.2021

Khmelnytskyi Green City Action Plan: Launch event and first stakeholder workshop - 28.04.2021

Green City Action Plan for Novi Sad Workshop Notification - 28.04.2021

Split Green City Action Plan kick-off meeting - 26.04.2021

Varna Green City Action Plan Stakeholder Workshops - 09.04.2021

Balti workshop on prioritising environmental challenges - 18.03.2021

EBRD Green Cities and GEI Webinar: Women Leading on Green - 11.03.2021

Warsaw Green City and Climate Action Plan (GCCAP) Launch Event - 03.12.2020

EBRD Green Cities Webinar #6: Creating Green Resilience in Cities - 24.11.2020

EBRD Green Cities Webinar: Hand in Hand – Green and Inclusive Recovery - 20.10.2020

EBRD Green Cities Webinar: Green Cities - smart solutions - 07.10.2020

Varna GCAP Public Consultation - 28.09.20 to 30.09.20

2020 Annual Assembly of ICLEI Taiwan Members & Sustainable City Forum - 29.07.2020

EBRD Green Cities Webinar: a Green Frontier - 01.07.2020

Pristina GCAP Public Consultation - 05.06.20 & 08/09.06.20

EBRD Green Cities Webinar: Transition to Recovery - 09.06.2020

Sofia GCAP Public Consultation - 27.04 - 27.05.2020

Sarajevo GCAP Public Consultation - 26.03 - 30.04.2020

World Urban Forum: EBRD Green Cities Linking Planning, Technology and Investment - 11.02.2020

Skopje GCAP Implementation - 24.01.2020

COP25 Event: EBRD Green Cities delivering policy and investments to scale up climate finance

Craiova GCAP Launch - 3.10.2019

Pristina GCAP Launch - 24.09.2019

Amman Green Actions Planning- 22.07.2019

Banja Luka GCAP Implementation - 11.07.2019

Ulaanbaatar Green Actions Planning - 27.06.2019

Sarajevo Green Actions Planning - 11.06.2019

Sarajevo Green City Action Plan Launch - 12.02.2019

Amman Prioritisation of Green Challenges - 11-12.06.2019

Minsk Green Actions Planning - 05.06.2019

Gyumri Green Actions Planning - 05.06.2019

Lviv Green Actions Planning - 29.05.2019

Batumi Green Actions Planning - 22.05.2019

Izmir GCAP Kick-Off Meeting - 2.05.2019

EBRD Green Cities: Building a better and more sustainable future for cities - 04.07.2019

Chisinau Green Actions Planning - 19.4.2019

Lviv Prioritisation of Green Challenges - 17.4.2019

Sarajevo Prioritisation of Green Challenges - 16.04.2019

Banja Luka Green Actions Planning - 12.04.2019

Sofia Green Actions Planning - 10.04.2019

Zenica Green Actions Planning - March 27 - 29 2019

Skopje GCAP Kick-Off Meeting - 27.03.2019

EBRD Sector Strategy Consultations - March 12 – 22 2019

Ulaanbaatar Prioritisation of Green Challenges- 06.03.2019

Batumi Prioritisation of Green Challenges- 28.02.2019

Amman GCAP Launch - 25.02.2019

Sarajevo GCAP Launch - 12.02.2019

Green City Action Plan Methodology

Stakeholder Engagement Guidance for Green City Action Plans

Green Cities Policy Report

Amman Green City Action Plan

Belgrade Green City Action Plan (local language)

Belgrade Green City Action Plan

Belgrade Sustainable Energy and Climate Action Plan (local language)

Belgrade Sustainable Energy and Climate Action Plan

Sarajevo Green Cantonal Action Plan

Sarajevo Green Cantonal Action Plan (Local Language)

Batumi Green City Action Plan

Batumi Green City Action Plan (Georgian)

Tbilisi Green City Action Plan

Gyumri Green City Action Plan

Gyumri Green City Action Plan (Armenian)

Tirana Green City Action Plan

Tirana Green City Action Plan (Albanian)

Ulaanbaatar Green City Action Plan

Ulaanbaatar Green City Action Plan (Mongolian)

Yerevan Green City Action Plan

Zenica Green City Action Plan

Zenica Green City Action Plan (Local Language)

Study of Urban Ventilation Corridors and Impact of High-rise Buildings (Local Language)

Study of Urban Ventilation Corridors and Impact of High-rise Buildings (English)

Green Cities 2 - Window I (GCF)

Green Cities 2 - Window II

Green Cities 2 - Window II Extension

Inception Report for the Almaty GCAP (English)

Inception Report for the Almaty GCAP (Russian)

Chișinău Green City Action Plan

Sofia Green City Action Plan

Sofia Green City Action Plan (Bulgarian)

Chișinău Green City Action Plan (Romanian)

Green City Action Plan Methodology (Russian)

Skopje Green City Action Plan

Skopje Green City Action Plan (Local Language)

Banja Luka City Action Plan

Banja Luka City Action Plan (Local Language)

Izmir Green City Action Plan

Izmir Green City Action Plan (Turkish)

Craiova Green City Action Plan (Romanian)

Craiova Green City Action Plan